Bitcoin: Reflections on the Lebanese Financial Crisis
Why do the Lebanese people suddenly care about Bitcoin?
I just flew in from San Diego to Lebanon for the holidays and a shocking number of my conversations with friends and family have been about Bitcoin.
Long story short, decades of government corruption and questionable policies by the Central Bank have led to a situation where depositors are not able to withdraw their money.
Small businesses are closing down, larger businesses are halving their workforces and salaries. All economic life has ceased while citizens wait for the ruling political class to come up with a solution which has so far been as timely as Godot.
To learn more about the Lebanese financial crisis, the below tweetstorm is the best summary I’ve read so far.
While in the United States, Bitcoin is a luxury investment technology, I will make the case that Bitcoin has an urgent use case as a savings technology in countries facing financial crises like Lebanon.
There is understandably an extreme amount of anger and grief directed towards our big opaque institutions. Why was it the case that the value of our savings was coupled to the decisions of our politicians and Central Bank? (Hint: This wasn’t the case during the Gold Standard)
What is Bitcoin?
Most Lebanese people now feel instinctively that maybe they don’t need banks and that maybe Bitcoin can help them free themselves from the banking system. But Bitcoin is complex and fundamentally different from any technology most people have worked with before.
Coming up with lucid arguments as to how exactly Bitcoin fixes a problem can become a hand-wavy exercise. I predict that Bitcoin will gain mass adoption in Lebanon in 2020 so it’s important that Lebanese citizens understand the technology and its implications
What’s lost is lost, Bitcoin won’t help you withdraw your money but it’ll make sure no-one is ever able to confiscate your money ever again.
My goal for this post is to equip you with the right arguments to have more productive discussions about Bitcoin with your Mom, Teta and besties. You’re going to be sitting with them over a Turkey dinner, mourning the loss of your monopoly dollars while you blame yourself for not seeing it coming.
Bitcoin is not just an alternative form of money, Bitcoin makes the entire business of Banks and Central Banks obsolete by separating the state from money.
No inflation, No interest rates
There will never be more than 21M Bitcoins in existence and no-one has the power to change that. Bitcoin removes the ability to print money. Printing money is a more politically palatable form of taxation and there is very little sound evidence as to why it’s actually necessary.
This means that contrary to all other modern inflationary currencies, Bitcoin is deflationary as in it increases in value over time as opposed to decreasing.
To counteract the inflation of cash, you’re often encouraged to deposit your money in banks where in Lebanon you can get up to 15% interest. In the US you would instead put your money in the stock market. It’s all good as long as the money is coming in until someday the effects of poor past decisions by the government and private companies add up to you losing significant part of your savings.
Bitcoin is not for speculators, Bitcoin is for those that cringe at the idea of debt, Bitcoin is for savers.
Easy money transfer
You can transact with anyone across the world without going through a bureaucratic 3rd party.
You don’t need a bank for local digital payments
You don’t need western union for international payments.
Making payments in Bitcoin is as easy as sending a message on Whatsapp. Pick a recipient and amount and you’re done!
Is it too new?
Bitcoin is new but so was the internet before it took over our lives and let anyone regardless of geography and socioeconomic status, learn anything. As amazing as the internet is, it still took 30 years to be what it is today.
30 years ago we could not have conceived how big of a part the internet plays in our lives and what kinds of new opportunities it could open up.
Many people reading this article have probably already seen the world around them change so much, why does money get a special status?
Aren’t Bitcoin transactions anonymous? How will we punish criminals?
Bitcoin is actually the opposite of anonymous, every single transaction between any 2 parties is recorded forever on thousands of servers all over the world. Anyone can audit these transactions without any sort of special approval.
Bitcoin would expose the true large scale criminals in our society but we may be disappointed to see that they’re all elected officials.
How can you use Bitcoin to save money if it’s volatile?
A lot of people remember Bitcoin’s famous crash from $20K, at the time there was a cryptocurrency mania very similar to the dot com bubble but the dot com bubble didn’t destroy technology, it only destroyed the fake technology companies. Similarly, the crypto was bubble may have been necessary for us to realize how good of a technology Bitcoin is.
As of December 2019, a single Bitcoin is worth over $7K so as an investment Bitcoin is the single most successful company of all time and it doesn’t have a CEO or employees.
Volatility isn’t inherently bad, volatility is bad if you’re choosing to quickly spend or cash out on your Bitcoin. If however, you’re willing to patiently hold your Bitcoin then your upside is massive. Satoshi theorized that a single coin could be worth $2M, there is no other investment or stock out there that can promise a multi million dollar return from a 7K investment.
Bitcoin incentivizes saving money.
Consider that your bank account is also volatile because there is always a risk of you not getting your deposits but the risk isn’t transparent to you. At least the Bitcoin network is always transparent about the actual value of your savings.
How will I get used to it?
When I talk about Bitcoin to my friends, they often mistake my enthusiasm for advice along the lines of: “convert all your savings and assets to Bitcoin”. I have not done this myself and would not recommend it to my friends. However, having 0 bitcoins is a more ridiculous position than converting all your money to Bitcoin.
But the real point is that before you invest in Bitcoin you need to educate yourself on Bitcoin and why it’s so special.
The fastest way to understand why Bitcoin is such a big deal is to read the Bitcoin Standard by Saifedean Ammous which is a thorough introduction to the history of money. It goes over the many advantages Gold had over paper money and presents Bitcoin as the first technology which stays true to and improves on Gold.
If you’re being entirely honest with yourself, before the financial crisis happened, did you really understand how money, banks and central banks work?
It’s not easy but it’s important to educate yourself on money because losing all your money is a big deal. You already spent so much time earning your money, why not spend a weekend learning how money works?
Isn’t Bitcoin used by criminals?
This is actually a hilariously bad critique of Bitcoin. When the internet was starting to be made available to general public, politicians and academics realized that they couldn’t broadcast their propaganda in a one way fashion to control what people thought so instead they argued that the internet should be banned because it contains some pages with porn and drug related content.
In fact, almost every single major technological breakthrough was met initially by resistance which seems ridiculous in retrospect.
AC Electricity→ Deadly technology because it’s used in electric chairs
Internet → Breeding ground for pornography and fake news
Bitcoin → Anarchy and Starvation
Criminals are often early adopters because their business involves lots of risk already and they are more than willing to experiment with new technology to stack the odds in their favor. That doesn’t mean that technology is bad.
Who controls Bitcoin?
Everyone and no-one. Bitcoin is a network that validates transactions between people, it makes all transactions transparent and it distributes the effort of validating transactions over the participants of a network.
While it does sound weird it is entirely possible to have distributed networks that outperform their centralized alternatives. Torrents are an example which outcompete streaming services like Netflix were they not made illegal.
Stores don’t accept Bitcoin
Stores don’t accept real estate as payment for the most part either, that doesn’t mean real estate is not a useful asset.
There is a growing number of people in Lebanon that would prefer to be paid in Bitcoin over US dollars because the dollar is also inflationary. Grocery stores and ABC are likely to follow as they will also want to decouple the money they’ll need to pay their suppliers from the banking system.
How do I buy Bitcoin?
This is actually the hardest part right now in Lebanon. Most Bitcoin exchanges require a bank deposit so you can buy your first coins. Unfortunately, the Lebanese banking system can’t help you much there but there are projects like Project Diaspora that are trying to make this process easier.
As of December 2019 the easiest way to buy Bitcoin is to purchase it directly in cash from a close friend that lives abroad.
How could Bitcoin fail?
By centralizing coins in a few conglomerates, a malicious group that controls over 51% of the Bitcoin network could start forcing incorrect changes to the Bitcoin ledger. However, as soon as this collusion is detected by others on the network (it’s easy to detect) then you can expect massive sell offs of Bitcoin which would crash the price of Bitcoin to 0. The people that would have the most to lose would be the people that own the biggest chunk of the networks, so by compromising the network the attackers would destroy the most valuable asset they’ve ever accumulated in their lives.
Bitcoin incentivizes cooperation.
Stop listening to people in fancy suits telling you what you need to do with your money. We don’t need more investment in crypto or blockchain and we don’t need banks, we just need people to start learning about Bitcoin and start owning small amounts of it.
To this day media companies belittle social media and the internet as an unreliable cesspool of fake news. We know this is false because there is no way we could have orchestrated a large scale peaceful demonstration without the internet. Financial institutions are far more powerful than the media and will resist far more violently to Bitcoin because there is far more at stake. The upside for the Lebanese citizen is however unbounded.
I wouldn’t understand Bitcoin if wasn’t for Saifedean Ammous. Read his book and watch all his talks.
I wouldn’t understand the Lebanese financial crisis if it wasn’t for the NERDS group on Twitter and the Project Diaspora Discord group. They gave me a warm peer group with an abundance of explanations and humor and are the one positive thing that’s come out of the Lebanese financial crisis.
I’m forever grateful.